01
1. Why the outline matters before you write
Most legal trouble in journalism is created at the drafting stage and discovered at the publication stage. A reporter who knows in outline what the law is interested in writes differently: they attribute contested claims, keep notes that support what they wrote, seek a response before publishing rather than afterwards, and know which sentence to take to somebody qualified.
That is the whole purpose of this chapter. It does not attempt to state defences, because a defence depends on the exact words, the evidence, the jurisdiction and the procedural history. It attempts something narrower and more useful for a learner: to identify the categories of duty, name the instruments and bodies that govern them in Ireland, and mark the point at which reading stops and professional advice starts.
02
2. Reputation and the Defamation Act 2009
Irish claims about damage to reputation are governed principally by the Defamation Act 2009. In outline, a claim concerns a published statement that carries a meaning damaging to the reputation of an identifiable person in the eyes of reasonable members of society. Each of those elements does work: publication, identification, and the meaning a reasonable reader would take, which may not be the meaning the writer intended.
For a reporter the practical consequences are concrete. Meaning includes implication, so a juxtaposition or a headline can carry a claim the text avoids. Identification does not require naming, and a description narrow enough to point at one person can identify them. Keeping evidence for what you published, recording when and how a response was sought, and having a second reader test the meaning are all ordinary practice rather than caution. What defences might apply in a specific case is a question for a solicitor.
03
3. Courts, contempt and reporting restrictions
Court reporting is closely constrained and the constraints are specific rather than general. Some categories of proceeding restrict what may be published about the parties, particularly where children or family matters are involved. Some hearings carry orders restricting reporting of particular details. Publishing material that could prejudice a pending criminal trial can amount to contempt.
The safe working habits are narrow and boring. Report what was said in open court accurately, attribute it to the proceeding, do not add material from outside the hearing beside an allegation, and check with the court registrar or the publication's legal adviser where any restriction may apply. Charges are allegations until determined, and copy should never let the running order suggest otherwise. If you are unsure whether an order applies, do not publish until somebody qualified has confirmed the position.
04
4. Privacy and data protection
Reporting involves processing personal data almost by definition: names, recordings, images, contact details, notes. The General Data Protection Regulation as given effect in Irish law governs that processing, with provisions relevant to journalistic purposes, and the Data Protection Commission is the supervisory authority for Ireland. The practical obligations that matter most to a working reporter are keeping only what you need, storing it securely, and being able to explain why you hold it.
Privacy is the separate question of whether publication intrudes on something a person is entitled to keep private, weighed against the public interest in publishing. Health, family life, sexual life, financial affairs, bereavement and the situation of children carry heightened expectations. The Press Council of Ireland's code addresses privacy directly, and it is a better starting point for a learner than any general principle.
05
5. Copyright and using other people's material
Text, photographs, video, audio, maps and diagrams are somebody's work, and finding a file online tells you nothing about permission to republish it. A screenshot of a social post reproduces the underlying work. Embedding, linking and copying are different acts with different consequences, and the fact that attribution has been given does not by itself make a reproduction lawful.
Ireland's copyright framework includes exceptions relevant to news reporting and to criticism and review, and they are narrower than newsroom habit assumes. The workable rules for a learner are to prefer material you created, to seek permission and record it, to keep a note of the licence where material is offered under one, and to take advice where a reproduction is central to the piece rather than incidental.
06
6. The Press Council of Ireland and the Press Ombudsman
Complaints about published journalism from member publications are handled by the Office of the Press Ombudsman, with appeals to the Press Council of Ireland, against a published code of practice covering accuracy, distinguishing fact from comment, fairness and honesty, respect for privacy, protection of sources, reporting of court proceedings and the treatment of children.
For a learner, the code is the single most useful document to read early, because it states in ordinary language what published Irish journalism is expected to do and what remedies exist when it does not. Reading it is not the same as being subject to it: Craft of Reporting is a teaching resource and is not a member publication, and nothing here implies membership, oversight or approval by either body.
07
7. Coimisiun na Mean and the wider regulatory picture
Coimisiun na Mean is Ireland's media regulator, with functions covering broadcasting and online safety alongside codes and rules that apply to regulated services. A reporter working in broadcast, or publishing on a platform that falls within a regulated category, needs to know which rules apply to the service they are publishing through, which is a different question from the general law of publication.
European instruments increasingly sit above both. Rules on transparency for very large online platforms, on advertising disclosure, and on the labelling of synthetic material affect how journalism is distributed rather than how it is written, but they change what a publisher must disclose. The practical advice for a learner is to identify the service you publish through and find out who regulates it before you need to know.
08
8. Ethics above the law
Lawful is not the same as defensible. The National Union of Journalists code of conduct sets out professional obligations that go beyond any statute: obtaining material by honest means, distinguishing fact from opinion, correcting harmful inaccuracy, avoiding intrusion into grief and shock, resisting distortion by editors or advertisers, and not producing material likely to encourage discrimination.
Those obligations are where most day-to-day decisions actually live. Whether to publish a detail that identifies a bereaved family, whether to use a photograph obtained from a private page, whether to press a distressed person for one more answer: no statute settles any of them. Write down the reasoning, take the decision at the right level, and be able to explain it to the person affected. That is the working definition of editorial ethics.
Where each question belongs
| Category | Question it asks | Irish reference point |
|---|---|---|
| Reputation | Does the published meaning damage an identifiable person? | Defamation Act 2009; advice from a solicitor |
| Court reporting | Is there a restriction, and is the trial pending? | The court itself; the publication's legal adviser |
| Personal data | Is this processing lawful, minimal and secure? | GDPR as applied in Ireland; Data Protection Commission |
| Access to records | Can I obtain this record from a public body? | Freedom of Information Act 2014 |
| Copyright | Do I have permission or an applicable exception? | Irish copyright legislation; the rights holder |
| Standards and complaints | Does this meet the published code? | Press Council of Ireland code; Office of the Press Ombudsman |
| Broadcast and online services | Which service rules apply to my publisher? | Coimisiun na Mean |
Pre-publication checklist for legal and ethical questions
- Every contested claim attributed, with the evidence retained and locatable.
- Meaning tested by a second reader, including headline, captions and juxtaposition.
- Response sought from anyone criticised, with the date and method recorded.
- Identification checked: could the description point to one person unintentionally?
- Court material limited to what was said in open court, restrictions confirmed.
- Third-party text, images and audio traced to a permission, licence or exception.
- Personal data held no longer than needed and stored securely.
- Any sentence you are unsure about referred to a qualified professional before publication.
Questions readers ask
Does this chapter tell me whether my article is safe to publish?
No. It names categories and instruments so you can ask better questions. Whether a specific text is safe depends on its exact words and evidence, and only a qualified professional can advise on that.
Is Craft of Reporting regulated by the Press Council of Ireland?
No. It is an independent teaching resource, not a member publication, and it claims no membership, approval or oversight by the Press Council, the Office of the Press Ombudsman, Coimisiun na Mean or the National Union of Journalists.
Can I publish something I found on a public social account?
Public availability is not permission. Copyright, privacy and the terms of the service can all apply, and a private grief or health detail on an open account can still raise a privacy question.